Avoiding vision whiplash 
If your coaching client’s ministry is constantly evolving their staff and congregation may be experiencing vision whiplash—and it’s painful. Here’s how to help…

Written By Robert E Logan

Christian Coaching Pioneer, Strategic Ministry Catalyst, Resource Developer, Empowering Consultant : Logan Leadership

You’re probably familiar with vision whiplash. It happens when a church or a faith community and the focus seems to shift every 6 to 12 months. It may be subtle. The vision statement doesn’t change but the focus, systems, and methodology does.

For a season, the church is “all about small groups.”  Then, without warning or explanation, you begin hearing that the church is “all about discipleship”– each ministry of the church is highlighting how it contributes to discipleship. Then a year down the road, the church is suddenly “all about being missional.” 

You get the idea. And you can even find yourself in agreement with all of these visions. They’re all good; they’re all biblical. But just when you feel yourself starting to get your mind wrapped around one central pillar, it’s gone. The center has changed. It may have changed to something good, but it has changed.

Results of Vision Whiplash

results and causes of vision whiplash

If a leader keeps changing focus all the time, the organization can feel like it has corporate ADD. The people within it start getting dizzy and confused. They also get to the point where they don’t feel they need to listen very carefully because they figure the focus will be changing again soon anyway. Leaders get major pushback even on good and necessary changes, even small ones. Lay leadership dwindles. 

Causes of Vision Whiplash

Many of the leaders you coach are unknowingly doing this to their congregations. From their perspective, they’ve focused on one approach and tried really hard and it just hasn’t seemed to catch on. So they move on to a different approach. But the sense of time from the perspective of those in the congregation is much shorter. Just when they begin getting used to an idea, it disappears. 

Identifying Vision Whiplash

If you suspect your client is dealing with some vision whiplash, lead them through some reflection to confirm. Questions like the following can help. Their answers can help them determine if they are causing vision whiplash.

  • Think back over the last ten years of your ministry. 
  • In what ways has the focus changed? 
  • How many different strategies or approaches have you tried? 
  • How often have you introduced a new system, curriculum, or focus? 
  • When have you seen people wearing out and dropping off? 

Coaching Tips to help

If there is a pattern of trying new things often, it’s likely their staff and congregation are feeling weary of change. It doesn’t mean they need to stop moving forward. Changes to their systems and methodology may still be needed. Part of your role as a coach may be helping them maintain a long-term implementation perspective, and helping them consider those who are involved. You can help them roll out a long-term plan to implement healthy and lasting change in their community. 

It’s likely, the problem isn’t the whole approach—the vision is good, the overall system is solid. It’s more likely there are elements that need to be fine tuned to better fit their context. Help your client consider the quantity and quality of communications, relational support, early pilot testing, and buy-in. 

There are costs to change, and trying to change everything all at once is extremely costly in terms of time, people, and finances. Sometimes it’s better to pivot: change strategic parts, but not everything all at once. And keep the costs—especially the changes in habits and processes others will have to adopt—in mind. 

There could be a lot of reasons that something isn’t working. Part of coaching your client well is helping them determine with more precision what those reasons are. It will save them—and those in their ministries—a lot of whiplash headaches in the long run. 

Resources

Change Management Effectiveness Profile– An assessment tool that provides a clear picture of overall ability to demonstrate effective change management. (Link will direct you to Logan Leadership)

Change Management Skills Builder– Once it’s been determined where to target development, this workbook provides activities in order to improve change management skills. (Link will direct you to Logan Leadership)

Managing Transitions: Making the Most of Change*- This classic book by William Bridges unpacks how to successful navigate change successfully. Hint: It works when staff and participants have a purpose, a plan, and a part to play.

Cover Photo by Kindel Media

Photo by Andrea Piacquadio

*Amazon affiliate link

Is Coaching Still Relevant?

The way ministry is done has changed a lot recently. Your coaching ministry is losing steam. People just aren’t engaging like they used to. Is coaching no longer relevant? Is there another system out there that is more effective?

Building Cultural Awareness for Effective Coaching

If you are working to make your coaching client list more diverse, the best place to start is with a refresher in cultural sensitivity

Coaching for Resourcing 

Fighting a scarcity mindset by helping clients see God’s provision.

A Military Strategy for Coaching Ministries?

Big changes are needed to halt the decline of the Church in America. However, even small changes can be met with heavy resistance. Many pastors have tried to implement healthy changes and admit that it feels almost impossible. Here is a strategy that might help.

The Organized Coach

If you are coaching more than a handful of people, you know it can get hard to track all the moving parts. Here’s how you can keep it all organized.

2 Areas of Your Coaching Business to Consider

You’ve got the basics of your coaching practice in order. You are a trained coach and you have a business plan in motion. But things are moving slower than you hoped. Here are some intangibles and nonessentials that, with some attention, might be just what you need. 

The Prepare—Engage—Act Coaching Cycle

The three-phase cycle that is the foundation for successful coaching sessions.

Building your coaching practice

There is a lot of information swirling about the internet on how to build a coaching practice. Some of it is good and some not so much. What is actually necessary for you and your coaching practice? Here are some misconceptions and 7 essentials for success. 

Helping clients define discipleship

Here’s a great exercise I picked up from Dave DeVries. If your client wants to make not just disciples, but disciplemakers– people who can make other disciples– here is an exercise to try… 

What to do when your client is stuck 

You have a coaching client who just isn’t moving forward on their goals. It happens to all of us. These 7 principles will help you troubleshoot and realign to gain momentum.