Coaching Through Personal Transitions
Why are transitions difficult?

Many of us struggle with making transitions because we are:
1. Comfortable - have become accustomed to our life and ministry
2. Risk averse - all transitions have a degree of risk involved
3. Waiting - discerning if this is God’s will

Written By Gary Reinecke

ICF Master Certified Coach, Resource Designer, Mission Strategist : InFocus

Personal Transitions

How many times have you heard leaders share that they are considering a “new ministry” opportunity? Sometimes, it is a natural response to the monotony of life; other times it is a case of the “grass is greener” fallacy. In other circumstances, a leader might find themselves in a leadership boundary they need to navigate in order to move forward into the next season of their development. When I coach leaders who are in personal transitions I like to highlight three phases:

  • Pre-transition: the time leading up to a transition where you sense a change coming, begin to pave the way and explore future ministry assignments.
  • Transition: announcing the change, resigning your current role and bringing closure in the healthiest manner possible to leave the organization in a healthier condition than when you arrived.
  • Post-transition: now in your new role doing the necessary actions to help you establish a new normal, building trust with new colleagues and engaging in the learning curve to adapt to your new team culture.

When coaching leaders through transitions I’ve borrowed three helpful questions from the Focused Living Retreat Workbook:

  1. Where have you been?
  2. Where are you going?
  3. How will you get there?

Seek Outside Help

coaching through personal transitions

I remember when I first came across a process that addressed question #1 – Where have you been? – I was a third year seminary student.  During my three years at seminary I was involved neck-deep in a new church plant.  I also had some personal drama in the background of my life including losing my mom to cancer during the first year of seminary.  In fact, the weekend the church went public I was on Spring Break at my mom’s bedside and was home when she passed.  About mid-way through my third year of seminary I had a come to Jesus moment and was told my services were no longer needed at the church plant by the lead planter.  I was a hot mess!

The final quarter of seminary I took a Leadership Development course.  My instructor, Dr. Gordon Klenck had returned from a 30-year stint as a missionary in what was formerly Eastern Europe. During his doctoral work at Fuller Seminary he was taking a course entitled Leadership Emergence Theory from Dr. Robert Clinton. The material was in the formative stages but the process helped me understand the process I had been in, how to turn the corner from the disappointment of the church plant and then focus on what I would eventually do following graduation. The exercise paved the way to synthesize my values in a way that helped me navigate the next season for my ministry development and set me on the trajectory that I continue on to this day.

When I coach others in that process I use the book “Stuck – Navigating the Transitions of Life & Leadership”, by Terry Walling to orient people to the leadership timeline Clinton developed.  I help them dig deeper into boundaries that separate one phase from another, take action and transition well. I would highly recommend this book. Perhaps the best advice I have on the topic is to enlist a trusted friend, colleague or coach who will help you process the three phases of a transition noted above.

Coaching for Personal Transitions

The process of discerning God’s will is not formulaic, nor is it linear; it is more like spaghetti. Imagine twirling your fork in a pile of noodles, finding a few that land on your utensils and into your mouth. This illustrates how the discernment process works. Once a leader has a sense that she/he is in transition, they begin the journey of twirling their fork. Going through this process in collaboration with a coach can help a leader move intentionally and fruitfully through a transition period.

Coaching Questions

10 questions to discern if you are in transition:

  1. What excites you about your current ministry?
  2. Are you becoming restless in your current role?
  3. Do you find yourself wandering about new challenges?
  4. Are other people noticing that your level of enthusiasm and passion is beginning to wane?
  5. Do you sense your time is coming to an end where you are currently serving?
  6. What would you do if you knew you could not fail?
  7. Where do you sense the Lord leading you in the future?
  8. Who do you know that could help you navigate the questions above?
  9. What tools have you used to help leaders assess where they are in their life and ministry development?
  10. Which tool would be most helpful for you to use to take the next step in your journey?

Photo by Christina Morillo from Pexels

Cover Photo by Jonathan Petersson from Pexels

Coaching to Develop Problem Solving Skills

Your clients come to you because they are stuck and need help moving forward. Often, because you are experienced and have the benefit of objectivity, you can pinpoint the problem and have a good idea where the solution lies. It’s tempting just to provide that help, knowing that clients will find it helpful. 

22 Questions to Ask the Mid-Sized Church

On the surface, finances might be healthy, facilities appear sufficient and staff are content. Underneath the veneer however there may be a high level of dissatisfaction – and reason for concern! What strategies do you use when coaching pastors of mid-sized churches? 

6 Strategies for Landing New Clients

You are poised and ready to help people and you are getting a lot of interest in coaching. Now you need to turn those potential clients into contracted clients.

Coaching the Small Church Pastor

There are wonderful things about working with small congregations, but just as with any church, there are potential pit-falls to be aware of from the perspective of a coach.

6 Ways You Can Upgrade Your Coaching Questions

You don’t just want to get your clients talking, you want the conversation to get deep, meaningful, and actionable. Upgrade your coaching questions from good to powerful.

5 Challenges Every House Church Faces

House Churches are becoming more common. Are you ready to coach their leadership toward effective ministry?

When church planters need coaching the most

No one likes feeling stuck. Coaching church planters when they are at critical sticking points helps them move forward with clarity and confidence. 

How to reboot your church board

If you feel like your board is tying your hands from moving forward effectively in ministry—or if your board members feel like you are tying their hands—there’s need for a reboot.

The best investment you can make in your church

It’s not a building or hiring additional staff members. And it’s not coming up with a new program. The best investment you can make in your church is to help develop the innate leadership skills in the people who are already there.

Slow Your Roll and Establish Disciple Making DNA

One of the pitfalls of launching small groups after the corporate gathering is established is that the DNA of disciple making can become secondary rather than primary.  This is a common problem when coaching church planters who, in their compulsion to “go public”, have found themselves relaunching two years later.  You as the church planter coach have influence in this decision.